Category: book Nook
OK, Ok, ok! I want oppinions on HP and the half blood prince! Do you think the locket is distroyed, what will happen in book seven ect!
Well seems that there are plenty of things to be tied up in the final book. Especially if there are all of those artifacts left to be found and destroyed.
does anyone have an opinion of who R.A.B. is? Do you think it's someone mentioned in one of the previous books, or someone knew. A friend and I were talking, and we could only come up with someone R.B., being reggulous black.
as for me i'm reading book 6 at the moment. just hope it gets better. i'm not enjoying it as it goes
I like book 6 very much. Didn't like it at first but it got better. What happens to Dumblidor is very very sad. I also think R.A.B is Reggulas Black. It is also very interesting to learn all those things about Voldemort's past. It helps understand him much better.
Oh wow what a question ... well I like the book. I always thought Snape was an asshole. Now he killed Dumbledore. I hope Dumbledore will still appear as a ghost or in the portrait to help Harry. Of course I am sure Harry will survive in book seven, and also his friends. I think Voldemort will be destroyed forever and Harry will get a job in the ministry. And will be with Ginny Weasley. Lol.
I expect that there will be a very, very hard fight at the end now. The hardest in all the books.
I think R. A. B is some person of the blacks. One of Sirius' bad family. I can't say more to this though.
Yes Ines, R A B is Sirius's brother Reggulas. Remember him? Actually, forgive the spoiler, but JK Rouling sort of confirmed my theory about him in an interview I read on the net. Check out her website guys, it's good!
Aah I am good. Yay. Hahaha. I thought so.
I thought that from the start. Only Voldomort's Death Eters call him the dark lord and Sirius' brother was a Death Eater so...
Yes, that's true.
What do you think about this: Once someone said "I odn'T think Dumbledore is dead". Do you think he will reappear as a ghost or at least talk through that portrait to Harry?
i think harry will get the artifacts and kill voldemort.
Yeah that is what I have thought, Shaf. It would be a good ending. I just think the book should give us a look into the future of Harry and his friends - what will they do after leaving Hogwarts, and all that. I also watn to know, even though I don'T like them, what happened to Draco and Snape.
Harry's next year won't be at Hogwarts. Maybe he'll visit there some time but he's leaving school and devoting all his time to finishing Voldemort off. I hope Dumbledore will appear on the next book as a ghost or some other form. I love him! And yes, it would be interesting to know what happens to Snape and Malfoy in the future. I think we'll see them among the death eaters. Looking forward to it.
Mmmh I do think he will be there again. I do think something during the holidays will make him come back to Hogwarts somehow.
Well, I for one can;t wait for the new book to come out! As for Dumbledore being in it... I'm not sure. I think it's going to take on a whole new dimension to other books in the past though, as if Harry is set to destroy the artefacts then he won't be based at Hogwarts. So then what happens to the friendships with Ron and Hermione?! And am I the only one who is addicted to Harry Potter who just wants to bang Ron and Hermione's heads together and say "come on... we all know you love each other... get together already!" I do honestly believe though that in order to kill Voldemort that Harry will die too. Kind of like one can't die without taking the other with them. Harry will have to give his life to save the world. A bit like Neo in the matrix trilogy. Just a thought, but it wouldn't surprise me if it happened!
oh, i love dumbledoor, he is so cool! he must apeer in the seventh book as a ghost.
No Lucy, I think I heard that J. K. Rowling said that harry will not die. And I am sure that something happens that Ron and Hermione will be with Harry again. And there *must* be a way that Harry is in Hogwarts again. I mean maybe the fight will be at hogwarts somewhere. What would the Harry Potter books be without HOgwarts ... it belongs to the books. Besides harry has to finish school before he ca nget a good job. I would imagine that he finishes the year, destroys Voldemort and goes for a job in the ministry to make it better. But that would just be little Ines' happy end. Lol.
Wow, so much to say, here we go. First of all, for those of us who have not been paying attention? Dumbledor does appear in the portrait in the headmaster's office after his death, so seeing as there is no reason that he shouldn't be able to communicate through the portrait as all of the previous headmasters and headmistresses of the school have done, then yes, of course he will still help Harry. Second of all I don't know for sure that Reggulous Black is the R A B mentioned. I looked back in the series and can't find any mention of his middle name, let alone his middle initial anywhere. It would be a nice little twist of fate for JKR to use him as a protagonist, even if he has already passed. It was mentioned that he was killed by the deatheaters, mayhap he went good, as opposed to going bad, after all. It would be rather coincidental for JKR to use both Serious and Reggulous as protagonists. She might be putting a spin on the family in general, a noble old wizarding family full of the dark lord's supporters, but turning out an unusual number of secret followers of the light. I am sure that Hogwarts will be used at least to some extent in the next book, for two reasons, first of all it is an integral part of the books, and Harry will still need some of the professors their as confidants and guides. I don't particularly care for the turn that the sixth book has taken, and I suppose that just as she has changed her writing style and tone in the last two books she may also take such a drastic step as to depart from Hogwarts completely, but I highly doubt it. Now, I may be wrong about this, as I was so disgusted with the newest book to have not yet reread it, but I believe that Ron and Hermione did indeed state that if Harry did not return to Hogwarts that they wouldn't do so either, and that they would help him in his self appointed mission. As for the horcruxes, with the ring destroyed by Dumbledore in the sixth book, and the diary destroyed by Harry in the second book, that would leave five of the seven origional horkruxes still to be dealt with. I don't think that she would leave the task of destroying quite that many to Harry with just one book left, so I believe that the locket has already been destroyed, and that only four remain for Harry and company to find and destroy. I have other objections to the book and further speculations to make, but my fingers are getting tired, so I'll poste more later.
Well now. I got the braille version of the sixth book back in August and I think Chapter 26 is the worst Harry Potter chapter I have ever read in all the 22 years I've lived. How could JK Rowling do that to Dumbledore? Anyway, I think four of the horcruxes have been found and destroyed already, including Slytherin's ring, so, All Harry has to do now is find the snake and destroy that, find the cup, destroy that and finally Voldemort and destroy him and live to tell the tale. He does, however, need Ron and Hermione. As we saw in the last book, one alone could not have gone over to the island in the middle of that lake , drunk that awful potion which caused intolerable pain to pick the Locket out of the bottom of the basin, got back in the boat and out of that place and lived long enough to destroy the locket and perhaps the other three horcruxes which were still to be found and dealt with and live to tell the tale. I myself cried buckets right the way through from when Dumbledore started to drink the twelve cups of potion, right through to the end of his funeral. It's just so shocking and sad.
I agree with "la musique ..." (sorry if I don't type your whole username), Dumbledore is still in the portrait - and you never know if there would even be a way that he reappears as a ghost. Lol
Whooow. Ok, I've got alot to say. I think that RAB is serius's brother for reasons stated in previous messages, but also this: Remember back in OotP when they were cleaning and they found a locket? One they couldn't open no matter what? Well, if Regulus was a deatheater, he could have switched sides, taken the locket, and what better place to hide it than in this old, abandoned house? A house with so much stuff that a mere locket would be over looked? Now, as to the seventh book, how does Rowling expect to make hary gain enough knowledge and strength to defeat voldemort in only one book and make it believable? Either it's going to be longer than OotP, or more rushed than HBP. Personally, rowling will have to work hard to redeme the series after book six.
Well you have a point there, but still I have heard that she said Harry will survive - and I guess there would be many angry readers.
ferst I am wanting to say that I am sure rab is reguless black next what about the this what if snape sead the unforgiveble curse but did some other curse that didn't kill him.
I don't think so mate, or Dumbledore would rise up out of the grave or something in Book 7. Maybe he does! we just don't know yet because book 7 isn't finished, let alone out in the shops yet.
I don't think so mate, or Dumbledore would rise up out of the grave or something in Book 7. Maybe he does! we just don't know yet because book 7 isn't finished, let alone out in the shops yet.
Which would be great, actually. I am sad that Dumbledore had to die. And I am sure, even if Harry is not in Hogwarts anymore, he will have enough power and friends to survive and kill Voldemort. Yay for me, I am an optimist. Lol
O, and Talest, nothing blocks Avada Kedavra! Sorry!
O, and Talest, nothing blocks Avada Kedavra! Sorry!
O, and Talest, nothing blocks Avada Kedavra! Sorry!
O, and Talest, nothing blocks Avada Kedavra! Sorry!
you have that three times
Ok, the whole multiple post thing is annoying. Anyways, Harry did see Dumbledore in the portrit, so Dumbledore will still be able to help Harry and will prob explain the whole thing between Snape and him. Do you think Snape is innocent, do you think he killed Dumbledore because of the unbreakable vow he made with Narcissa to protect Draco, or was he acting on Voldemort's orders? I still would like to believe that Snape is innocent, but we'll just have to weight and see. Also I do believe that RAB is Sirius's brother and the locket is the same one they saw in OOTP. Hermione and Ron already said they would stick by Harry no matter what, so will go with him to destroy the horcruxes. If Harry, Hermione, or Remus end up dying at the end, I'm just going to hate the entire series and never read it again. Hmm, too tired to think of more to write for now. O yeah, and I hate the whole Harry/Ginny and Ron/Hermione thing. I would have liked Harry and Hermione together, but o well.
Snape is not innocent. I even think he acted on Voldemort's orders - or because he promised Narzissa to take care of Draco. Dunno.
Snape is a jerk in all the sense of the word! This is why I believe that he did intend to kill Dumbledore on Voldemort's orders and even went on to perform the killing curse. And, no one survives the Avada Kedavra curse? What did Harry Potter survive then. Remember why he was able to survive the killing curse that was NOT meant to allow him to live past the age of one? It was because his mother died to save him. Because she had a love so strong and her willingness to protect him from danger exceeded her fear of Voldemort. I should Dumbledore is still probably somehow biding his time. I think that Harry showed to Dumbledore what Harry's mother showed him when she died to save his life.
No, No, No, that is not why Harry did not die when he was One. Harry didn't die because the proficy said that Voldemort will mark him as his equal. people Get a clue! The only reason that Harry didn't DIE is because the proficy had to be fulfilled. His mother dieing has nothing to do with Harry living after Voldemort tried to kill him. Waht she gave him was the protection that Voldemort could not tuch him and not have great pain himself. If Voldemort would have hared the hole thing then he would not have atacked harry at all.
I start to wonder. we know that Dumbledor is dead and we know that he has a portrat but it's been a year since the sixth book and I know that there is an epologue and that the last word of the book is "Scar"
So what's your point?
I know that many people are hoping that Harry doesn't die. I have actually heard Daniel Radcliffe's theory on how this series will end. He seems to think that if Harry does get killed by Voldemort, Voldemort will also succeed in killing himself. Do any of you think this would fit the last line of the prophecy. "Neither can live, while the other survives."? It might make sense. I don't know. We'll have to wait and see.
No both won't die, because that contradicts the proffacy. I say we kidnap Rowling and force her to tell all at gun point. And snape is good, not evil.
We'll have to wait for 7,7,07 won't we.
Unfortunately, we'll have to wait until the 21st of July. SEVERUS SNAPE IS PURE EVIL! Remember what Harry said at the end ? "I'm not coming back even if it does reopen." So even if Hogwarts is in the last book, it might only be there as a reference. I've read that J. K. Rowling is bringing back that mirror from the first book. So many questions! lol
there is a theory out there that Dumbledore was dying from the curse or that Snaped stoppered his death but that it wouldn't last forever. the theory is that Dumbleddore ordered Snape to unstopper his death or that the potion he drank at the cave was killing him. If so Snape was working on Dumbledore's orders. I'm still a believer that there is more to snape than meets the eye. Him being pure evil is a bit too obvious.
Maria
That makes sense. I've seen stories where Snape is a total good guy but that is just me. I've been reading too much fanfiction lately.
Like I said, he's very complex, and we'll know where his loyalties lie, come July 21st midnight.
oh wow.... I don't know what to say here. I am thin king so many things that... wow. LOL. Ok, first of all, I do think that there's got to be some method to JK's madness. Only the writer after all, knows where they are going with their writing. I don't think that the last couple books have been any less than the first ones. I just think she changed it up because of how she was planning to end the series. I do wonder about snape, think that he can't've all been bad, as someone who didn't give a d**n wouldn't've saved Harry's life. But that's just me. As far as the R. A. B. thing, the locket found at 12 Grimmald Place is definitely something to consider. I love JKR and nothing anyone ever says will change that! Unless of course... she goes and commits like... some murders or something, then I'll reconsider the wisdom of that statement...